All
Forums
Go to Google Groups Home    Feedback & Suggestions
Re: Feedback on New Video Upload Redesign Beta

justinrussell

I completely agree regarding the time length limit. I spent 3 hours
today attempting to upload a 45-minute video; it was well under 1 GB,
but as I found out when I visited my channel, it was rejected due to
its length.

I'm really disappointed that YT has made such a glaring usability
error, especially when it would be so straightforward to add the limit
to the "About Uploading" area. By omitting it from that area while
showing all the other major requirements, it makes the user feel as
though any time limit is acceptable as long as the video is in the
right format and under 1 GB in size.

On Nov 21, 3:49 am, markthomasnz wrote:

> Hi I made the following post elsewhere it probably should have been
> here... apologies if youve had to read it twice...

> I completely understand why there needs to be a file size limit, but
> why on earth have a time limit? The only thing that matters is
> bandwidth not video length.

> I didnt realise there was a 10.59min limit, only that there was a 1GB
> limit.

> Ive spent hours uploading videos that have been rejected and thus
> wasting mine and youtube's bandwidth doing so. in some cases theyve
> been uploading even after the time/size was well exceeded but they
> just carried on loading and wasting bandwidth.

> Why oh, why can youtube servers not check the file size (and if
> necessary) the
> file's time length) PRIOR to upload and immediately tell user the file
> is not suitable THEN, so the user doesn't spend hours wasting
> everyones time and bandwidth.

> like others say a load progress bar would be great

> cheers.

> On Sep 28, 12:54 pm, YouTube Timmy wrote:

> > Hey all,

> > We just released the beta version of our new and improved video
> > uploader. If you want to check it out, just login to your YouTube
> > account and click this link to opt in:http://www.youtube.com/my_videos_upload?beta

> > The new video upload flow includes these cool features:

> >     • You can enter in your video's metadata (title, description,
> > tags, etc.) while the upload is processing.

> >     • Upload multiple files at once, without downloading a plugin
> > (separate progress bars will display for each file).

> >     • The file-size limit for uploads has been raised from 100MB to
> > 1GB.

> > Let us know what you think of the new uploader by replying to this
> > post.

> > Thanks!
> > YouTube Timmy